Home Loan Prepayment vs SIP Calculator

Should extra money go into your home loan or into a SIP? This calculator gives both paths the same cash every month. The prepayment path pays the extra into the loan and, once the loan closes, invests the EMI and extra it no longer owes. The SIP path pays the normal EMI and invests the extra. Results are estimates based on your assumptions.

Important: These are simplified scenarios

  • Home-loan path: Estimates interest under a constant-rate, monthly reducing-balance model. It does not include lender charges, changes in interest deductions, or actual payment-posting rules.
  • SIP path: Applies the return input as a steady monthly growth rate. Actual investment returns vary and may be higher or lower; taxes and costs may also differ.
  • Same cash, same return: Both paths spend the same amount every month. After the prepaid loan closes, the EMI and extra cash it frees are invested at the same assumed return, and both paths are compared at the original loan end.

Loan Details

= Fifty Lakh Rupees

Monthly EMI

₹43,391

Prepayment Strategy

= Ten Thousand Rupees

Extra amount added to EMI every month

The SIP path invests this same extra cash on the same dates.

Once the prepaid loan closes, the prepayment path invests the freed EMI and extra cash at the same return.

SIP Investment Settings

Scenario input only; the calculator divides this rate by 12 and applies the same monthly return throughout. It is not a forecast.

Higher modeled balance at original loan end

📈 SIP Investment

Modeled difference

₹26.98 L

Break-even: SIP path stays ahead from month 2 (Year 1)

Scenario output only, at the original loan end. Both paths get the same cash; the prepayment path invests what it frees after the loan closes. Not a recommendation.

Prepayment Path

Interest Saved

₹21.79 L

Time Saved

7 years 1 months

Loan Closed In

12 years 11 months

Total Paid (EMI + Prepayment)

₹82.35 L

Corpus from freed EMI + extra (after closure)

₹71.94 L

SIP Investment Path

Final Corpus

₹98.93 L

Total Invested

₹24.00 L

Gains

₹74.93 L

Net Worth Comparison

Net worth = Assets (SIP corpus) - Liabilities (Loan balance). Prepayment path shows faster debt reduction; SIP path shows corpus growth alongside loan repayment.

Share This Comparison

Share link preserves your inputs. Downloaded image includes watermark with indianfinestimator.com

How This Calculator Works

This calculator simulates two parallel scenarios month-by-month:

  1. Prepayment Path: Your extra cash reduces the loan principal, saving interest and shortening tenure. Once the loan closes, the EMI and extra cash you no longer owe are invested at the same return. Net worth = that corpus - remaining loan.
  2. SIP Path: You pay the standard EMI and invest the same extra cash on the same dates. Net worth = SIP corpus - remaining loan.

Both paths spend exactly the same money every month, and the comparison is read at the end of the original loan tenure, when both loans are closed.

Important Considerations

  • Assumptions: Loan rate is held constant and interest is modeled monthly. SIP growth is a steady rate selected by you; actual returns are uncertain.
  • Liquidity: Cash paid toward a loan may not be readily available again. SIP redemption rules, market value, and taxes depend on the investment.
  • Tax: Tax is off by default. If enabled, the calculator applies one rate and one exemption to the total modeled gains on each path; it does not model lot-level SIP taxation or possible changes to home-loan deductions.
  • Psychological: Being debt-free has value beyond numbers. Consider your peace of mind.

Disclaimer: This calculator provides estimates for educational purposes only. Actual returns on investments can vary significantly. Loan terms and prepayment options depend on your lender's policies. Tax laws may change. Consult a financial advisor before making major financial decisions.

Worked example: ₹50 lakh loan, ₹10,000 extra a month

Loan of ₹50,00,000 at 8.5% for 20 years (EMI ₹43,391), with ₹10,000 a month available on top of the EMI and an assumed 12% annual return:

  • Prepayment path: the loan closes in 12 years 11 months instead of 20 years, saving an estimated ₹21.79 L of interest. The EMI and extra it no longer owes are then invested for the remaining 7 years 1 month, reaching about ₹71.94 L.
  • SIP path: the loan runs the full 20 years, and ₹10,000 a month invested for 20 years reaches about ₹98.93 L.
  • At the 20-year mark both loans are closed. At a 12% assumed return the SIP path is ahead by about ₹26.98 L, before tax. The prepayment path carries no market risk on the interest it saves; the SIP figure depends on the assumed return.

How the answer changes with the assumed return

Corpus at 20 years on each path for different assumed annual returns, same ₹50 lakh loan at 8.5%
Assumed returnPrepayment path at 20 yearsSIP path at 20 yearsAhead (pre-tax)
7%₹59.20 L₹52.09 LPrepayment by ₹7.10 L
8.5%₹62.70 L₹62.70 LAbout equal
10%₹66.47 L₹75.94 LSIP by ₹9.47 L
12%₹71.94 L₹98.93 LSIP by ₹26.98 L

Same cash on both paths every month; returns compounded monthly; no tax, fees or Section 24(b) effects. The equal result at 8.5% holds before tax only. With the optional LTCG estimate on (12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh), prepayment stays ahead below about 9.05% and the SIP path ends ahead from there, because the paths pay different modeled tax. Change any input in the calculator above to see your own figures.

How this is calculated

  1. EMI = P × r × (1 + r)n ÷ ((1 + r)n − 1), where P is the loan, r the monthly rate (annual rate ÷ 12) and n the tenure in months.
  2. Each month, interest = outstanding balance × r. The EMI minus that interest, plus any prepayment, reduces the balance.
  3. Every month both paths have the same budget: EMI + the extra cash from your plan. Whatever a path does not pay into its loan that month is invested, and the investment grows at the assumed return compounded monthly.
  4. Net worth on each path = invested corpus − loan still outstanding. The paths are compared at the end of the original tenure, when both loans are closed.

How to compare the choices

Compare the interest and any fees under your lender's actual repayment terms with investment outcomes across several assumptions, after applicable taxes and costs. The loan rate, tax eligibility, payment timing, investment risk, and access to cash can all change the result. No single rate threshold predicts which choice will be better for everyone.

  • Ask your lender how a proposed payment changes the EMI or tenure, when it will reduce principal, and whether a fee applies.
  • Check tax relief only if you meet the rules for your property, loan, ownership, and tax regime. Income Tax Department guidance on the tax regimes.
  • Keep enough accessible savings for planned expenses and emergencies; money used to prepay may be harder to access again.
  • Compare more than one investment return assumption and include tax and costs. The calculator is a simplified illustration, not a complete financial plan.

For the reasoning behind each factor, read Prepay Home Loan vs SIP: The Math.

Check whether RBI's prepayment rule covers your loan

The standalone RBI prepayment notification issued in 2025 has been withdrawn. Its prepayment-charge instructions are now set out in lender-category-specific Master Directions. Find the direction for your lender and check its scope against the loan purpose, sanction or renewal date, and rate type on the payment date. Open the RBI Master Directions index.

Bank-Specific Prepayment Rules

Confirm the latest lender process for your loan: eligible payment channels, minimums or frequency, payment posting date, any applicable charges, and whether you can choose a lower EMI or shorter tenure.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is it better to prepay the home loan vs invest in a SIP?

It depends on how the loan rate compares with the after-tax return you assume, and on how sure that return is. Before tax, with the same cash on both paths, the model gives the same result when the assumed return equals the loan rate; prepayment ends ahead below that rate and the SIP path ends ahead above it. With the optional LTCG estimate on, the two paths build different gains and so pay different modeled tax: in the worked example on this page (₹50 lakh at 8.5%, 12.5% LTCG above ₹1.25 lakh), prepayment stays ahead below about 9.05% and the SIP path ends ahead from there. Returns are not guaranteed, and the result also depends on tax eligibility, fees and the cash you need to keep accessible.

Is there a penalty for prepaying a home loan in India?

It depends on your loan, lender, and applicable rules. RBI prepayment-charge instructions are set out in lender-category-specific Master Directions. Find the direction for your lender and check the loan purpose, sanction or renewal date, rate type on the payment date, and your loan documents.

Does prepaying a home loan affect my Section 24(b) tax benefit?

It may: a lower balance can reduce the interest paid, which may change a deduction you are eligible to claim. Eligibility and limits depend on the property, loan, and tax regime. The Income Tax Department says the Section 24(b) interest deduction for a self-occupied property is not available under the new tax regime. This calculator does not model that deduction.

Should I prepay home loan or invest if I am in the 30% tax bracket?

Your tax bracket alone does not decide it. Check whether you can actually claim a home-loan deduction, how prepayment changes that claim, the investment tax treatment, and whether the assumed return compensates for market risk. Compare your own figures and several return scenarios.

What is the break-even point in prepayment vs SIP?

The break-even month is the month from which the modeled SIP path stays ahead of the modeled prepayment path until the original loan end. It depends on the return you assume, so treat it as an illustration rather than a forecast.

How does LTCG tax affect SIP returns vs loan prepayment?

The optional tax estimate applies one rate and one exemption to the total modeled gains on each path: the SIP corpus, and the corpus the prepayment path builds after the loan closes. It is not a lot-by-lot or annual tax calculation, and actual tax depends on the asset, holding period and tax year.

Is loan prepayment a guaranteed return?

Prepayment reduces future interest under your loan terms, and that saving does not depend on markets. It is not automatically a yield equal to the loan rate, because rate resets, fees, payment timing and tax deductions can change it. SIP returns are uncertain.

Can I split between prepayment and SIP?

You can allocate money to both, based on your cash needs and risk tolerance. This calculator models one strategy at a time and does not calculate a combined plan. Run each option with consistent inputs, then use your lender’s schedule to check how actual payments affect the loan.

Related calculators

This calculator is for informational and educational purposes only. Results are estimates based on the assumptions you provide and may not reflect actual returns. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Please consult a SEBI-registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.